American Mindset

Share this post

Power and Principle

americanmind.substack.com

Power and Principle

The American Mind
Apr 6, 2021
7
5
Share this post

Power and Principle

americanmind.substack.com

The age-old question in right-leaning politics and political philosophy is how to do more good than harm … or at the very least: how to minimize harm. The libertarian default on legislation or policy revision, rightly born of long study and experience of unintended consequences, is “don’t just do something, stand there.” The default on the Left was once amusingly immortalized by Ronald Reagan as, “if it moves, tax it; if it keeps moving, regulate it; and if it stops moving, subsidize it.” Even cliches, stereotypes, and dogmas have their place of course.

But in the current American age of cultural, institutional, and ideological domination by the Left, right-wingers of all varieties need to do better. I know it is a tired invocation on the Right, but the Founders provide a pretty good model. They took a prudential rather than an ideological (or absolutist) view of governmental power. The conclusion was never: more government, bad; less government, good. The questions were always: what power, exercised by whom, and to further or achieve what purpose? The Articles of Confederation were inadequate to secure America’s safety, prosperity, and the protection of the citizenry’s rights because the national government was too weak. The Constitutional convention resulted in a dramatic expansion of the power and jurisdiction of the national government and it was an increase in justice and a boon to the American people’s happiness and prosperity.

Many conservatives and libertarians have of late been decrying various efforts by red-state legislatures to act like they care about their constituents—and some GOP governors are thwarting legislative majorities by vetoing these efforts. South Dakota’s Kristi Noem tried to veto-but-not-quite-veto her legislature’s attempts to protect women’s sports in the state from competition by biological men “identifying” as women. Arkansas governor Asa Hutchinson vetoed a bill this week that sought to protect confused minors from being prescribed and undergoing irreversible changes to their physiology through hormone therapy or surgery (euphemistically known as “gender affirming care”). As I write this, the legislature just overrode his veto, with most of the state’s parents who are paying attention sighing in relief. The Georgia legislature has gone half-way in ending an aviation fuel subsidy for Delta in retaliation against the airline CEO’s criticism of the Peach State’s latest voting law.

The logic from some on the Right seems to be: “let’s not do what the Left does and use government power to protect friends and punish enemies. We’re principled, after all, and on top of that, if we give the government more power to help ourselves now, then when the other side takes over it will be used against us.” But let us be practical and prudent. The only real power in America that the Right has now is political, especially in the states. America’s largest corporations, Big Tech, most of the media, most of the mainline churches, Hollywood, schools, and universities, etc—all are in the grip of the latest ideological fads of leftism. Conformity with these fads, in word and deed, is being fanatically enforced across civil society and by national and state governments and bureaucracies. The stakes are high and the time to fight is now—wielding whatever levers of power are available. 

Will the other side abuse governmental power if the tables are turned? Of course, but that will happen regardless. Part of the Right’s losing strategy in recent years has been to forget a key lesson of game theory: if you never wield power in defense of your interests, exacting real costs on the other player, you cannot expect any modification of behavior by your opponent. The Right needs to think less dogmatically and more creatively about defending its friends and constituents and exchanging tit for tat. In fact, let’s demand that GOP politicians engage in some “bold, persistent experimentation” in defense of the rights and interests of the citizenry—because after the conservative “victories” of recent years, who needs losses?


Ryan P. Williams (@RpwWilliams) is the President of the Claremont Institute. He is the Publisher of the Claremont Review of Books and The American Mind.
5
Share this post

Power and Principle

americanmind.substack.com
5 Comments
Buddy Glass
Apr 7, 2021

Is there more autism and breast cancer than there used to be? No. There's more talk about it. More venues for information flooding. One reason is the influence of celebrities. When a celebrity talks, people listen. A more important reason is that M.D.s are better at diagnosing these disorders. Are the problems facing America today more numerous and more severe than any in the history of the human race? I wouldn't go that far. In America, life was chancy and difficult in the 1600s, 1700s, 1800s, and much of the 1900s. Life could be nasty, brutish, and short. This is one area where historical perspective is actually a benefit. If there appear to be many many problems today, then there will be many many eggheads offering many many solutions. And you know what they say about opinions and free advice. Many unskilled people want power because they think they have the answers. And because they are looking for a job. The American tradition has been not that power is all bad, but it needs to be dispersed. John Adams said power was poison. Even if I took that seriously as a political philosophy, which I do, I know that Botox is a poison that can straighten the lines in your face. I know that running for office necessarily means trying to get power. A football coach has power. Parents have power. Power tends to corrupt, and usually does. But that's all the more reason to choose wisely, to place limits, to avoid giving any one person or group too much power. How much is too much? Ask the people involved. Why is the judge's chair higher than the rest of us, so we have to hurt our necks looking up? I don't know. It's wrong. Those chairs should be removed.

Expand full comment
Reply
Lew
Apr 7, 2021

Any infliction on the woke left has to be felt. Such as the burning of buildings and physical harm by the Marxist Left BLM. Violence should never be abandoned as abhorrent as it is. Fight back or face defeat. There is no longer time to write Congress letters of distain. The Left believes voting is the pablum of the masses. Civility is over due to the big leftist lie. Civil War must be understood as the only means now to fight the illegitimate Communist government that has taken over DC and is and will continue to destroy this country. Americans are going to have to wake up in the face of the forces of woke evil and be prepared to go to war against the enemy that lies within. And take back the last free nation on earth. Listen to every word of the xKGB Yuri Besmenov’s 1980s interview on the stages of Communist subversion. We are there.

Expand full comment
Reply
2 replies
3 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 The American Mind
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing